
SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY – An Islip Terrace man has been sentenced to 10 years in prison for deliberately setting fire to an East Islip bar after employees asked him to leave the establishment, according to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office.
Paul Lucia, 61, received the sentence on November 17, 2026, after pleading guilty to second-degree arson and related charges stemming from a November 2025 fire at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant. The fire damaged an exterior awning and the kitchen while patrons and employees were present at the establishment. No injuries were reported.
Dispute at East Islip Bar Preceded Fire
According to court documents and Lucia’s admissions during his guilty plea, the incident began on November 20, 2025, at approximately 5:30 p.m., when Lucia was drinking at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant in East Islip.
Staff members asked Lucia to leave after he took a photograph of an employee. Lucia complied with the request and drove away in a white Jeep Patriot, but returned approximately two hours later with a gas can and a lighter.
Surveillance footage showed Lucia exiting his vehicle at approximately 7:30 p.m. and pouring liquid from the gas can near the restaurant’s rear entrance, which was open and occupied by customers and employees at the time.
Moments later, flames erupted on the premises. Prosecutors said Lucia walked back toward his vehicle, threw the gas can over a fence onto an adjoining property and drove away from the scene.
The fire damaged the restaurant’s exterior awning and kitchen. Despite the presence of employees and customers, nobody was injured.
Surveillance Footage and Physical Evidence
Investigators were able to identify Lucia’s vehicle after a witness provided police with the license plate number of the white Jeep Patriot seen leaving the scene. Authorities subsequently determined that the license plates had been reported stolen approximately one week before the fire.
Detectives assigned to the Suffolk County Police Department’s Arson Squad examined the property and recovered the cap from a gas can inside a flowerpot outside the establishment. The gas can itself was recovered from the neighboring property where Lucia had allegedly discarded it.
A certified canine from the Suffolk County Fire Marshal’s Office was also brought to the scene and alerted investigators to the presence of ignitable liquids in several locations.
On November 21, 2025, the day after the fire, Suffolk County police officers located Lucia driving the white Jeep along Sunrise Highway and conducted a traffic stop. Lucia was arrested, and investigators recovered a lighter from inside the vehicle that prosecutors identified as having been used in the arson.
Guilty Plea and Prison Sentence
On October 13, 2026, Lucia appeared before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard Horowitz and pleaded guilty to four criminal charges, including Arson in the Second Degree, a class B violent felony; Arson in the Third Degree, a class C felony; and two counts of Criminal Possession of Stolen Property in the Fifth Degree, class A misdemeanors.
On November 17, 2026, Lucia was sentenced to 10 years in state prison, followed by five years of post-release supervision.
Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney said the case demonstrated how an ordinary disagreement could escalate into a dangerous criminal act.
“What began as a simple request for the defendant to leave the premises escalated into an unwarranted and dangerous act of arson,” said Tierney.
Tierney also credited investigators for collecting the evidence necessary to prosecute the case and secure Lucia’s guilty plea.
Arson Investigation and Prosecution
The investigation was conducted by Detectives John Boreshesky and Michael Langella of the Suffolk County Police Department’s Arson Squad.
Assistant District Attorneys Sean Lorthioir and Jeremy Waite of the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Major Crime Bureau Arson Unit prosecuted the case.
According to the District Attorney’s Office, members of the Arson Unit have received specialized training in arson investigation and prosecution from certified fire investigators associated with the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives and the New York State Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services.
Key Facts & Details
| Defendant | Paul Lucia, 61 |
| Residence | Islip Terrace, Suffolk County, New York |
| Incident Location | Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant, 148 Carleton Avenue, East Islip, New York |
| Incident Date | November 20, 2025 |
| Initial Dispute | Approximately 5:30 p.m., after Lucia photographed an employee and was asked to leave |
| Time of Fire | Approximately 7:30 p.m. |
| Property Damage | Exterior awning and kitchen |
| Reported Injuries | None |
| Arrest Date | November 21, 2025 |
| Guilty Plea | October 13, 2026 |
| Convictions | Second-degree arson, third-degree arson and two counts of fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property |
| Sentencing Date | November 17, 2026 |
| Prison Sentence | 10 years |
| Post-Release Supervision | Five years |
| Presiding Judge | Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard Horowitz |
| Defense Attorney | Michael Elbert, Esq. |
| Prosecutors | Assistant District Attorneys Sean Lorthioir and Jeremy Waite |
| Investigating Agency | Suffolk County Police Department, Arson Squad |
| Additional Investigative Assistance | Suffolk County Fire Marshal’s Office |
| Prosecuting Agency | Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office, Major Crime Bureau Arson Unit |
| Original Police Report | Suffolk County Police Department – November 21, 2025 |
The November 2025 fire prompted an investigation involving surveillance footage, witness information, recovered physical evidence and specialized fire investigators. Nearly one year after the incident, Lucia’s guilty plea resulted in a 10-year prison sentence and an additional five years of post-release supervision.
