Seafood Markets
Fresh seafood markets on Long Island range from neighborhood fishmongers and dockside markets to seafood distributors with public retail counters. The directory below includes 50 physical markets across Nassau County and Suffolk County, with addresses, contact information and market services.
Fresh seafood is not automatically the same as locally caught seafood. Markets that specifically document Long Island or local landings are identified below, while other entries are described only by the products and services they publicly advertise. Selection can change daily and seasonally, so customers looking for a particular fish, shellfish species or quantity should call before traveling.
Map of Fresh Seafood Markets on Long Island
Use the interactive map to find seafood markets across Long Island. Select a marker for the market address, telephone number, visitor information, website and driving directions.
Fresh Seafood Markets in Nassau County
This is a geographic directory rather than a ranking or endorsement. Hours, product availability, ordering methods and seasonal schedules can change. Contact the market directly before making a special trip or placing a large order.
Albertson Fine Seafoods
1032 Willis Avenue
Albertson, NY 11507
516-218-3498
Family-operated seafood market offering fresh and frozen seafood, prepared specialties and catering.
Fish Net
918 Main Street
South Farmingdale, NY 11735
516-694-7419
Neighborhood fish market; call before visiting to confirm current selection and hours.
Captain Ben’s Fish Market
319 Woodcleft Avenue
Freeport, NY 11520
516-378-6575
Retail fish market on the Nautical Mile with fresh fish and shellfish.
Two Cousins Fish Market
255 Woodcleft Avenue
Freeport, NY 11520
516-379-0793
Public retail market open seven days a week; established on the Nautical Mile in 1969.
Artie’s South Shore Fish Market
4257 Austin Boulevard
Island Park, NY 11558
516-889-0692
Fish market and seafood grill operating in Island Park since 1974; raw and prepared seafood available.
Jordan Lobster Farms
1 Pettit Place
Island Park, NY 11558
516-889-3314
Fish and lobster market sourcing from local fishermen and other suppliers; prepared foods, restaurant and catering also available.
Lynbrook Seafood
246 Hempstead Avenue
Lynbrook, NY 11563
516-599-8899
Retail seafood market; contact the shop for the day’s selection, ordering and pickup information.
Captain Mike’s Seafood & Lobster
3388 Long Beach Road
Oceanside, NY 11572
516-678-4522
Fresh seafood and lobster market with pickup and delivery advertised; call to confirm availability.
Sea World Sushi & Fish Market
201 N. Long Beach Road
Rockville Centre, NY 11570
516-678-5730
Fresh fish market with sushi and prepared seafood; call ahead for current offerings.
Syosset Seafood
293 Robbins Lane
Syosset, NY 11791
516-681-3474
Fresh seafood, sushi, prepared foods, soups and sides; the market advertises delivery service.
New Wave Seafood
1847 Wantagh Avenue
Wantagh, NY 11793
516-783-4900
Fresh seafood market with prepared dishes, restaurant service and catering.
Jewel of the Sea at Victoria’s Market
8049 Jericho Turnpike
Woodbury, NY 11797
516-496-2416
Seafood counter and market offering fresh seafood, sushi and prepared foods within Victoria’s Market.
Point Lookout Clam Bar & Fish Market
99 Bayside Drive
Point Lookout, NY 11569
516-897-4024
Year-round dockside fish market with fresh fish, shellfish and sushi; much of the seafood is documented as locally landed.
Fresh Seafood Markets in Suffolk County
B&B Fish & Clam
179 Merrick Road
Amityville, NY 11701
631-608-0202
Fish and clam market with a prepared-food kitchen and pickup ordering.
Captree Clam Seafood Company
440 Falmouth Road
West Babylon, NY 11704
631-422-0517
Retail and online seafood seller specializing in Long Island clams and oysters, plus scallops, lobster, shrimp and mussels.
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Highway
Bayport, NY 11705
631-472-3018
Fresh fish market with prepared seafood, catering, pickup and delivery.
Southside Fish & Clam
395 W. Montauk Highway
Lindenhurst, NY 11757
631-226-4700
Fresh fish market and seafood restaurant operating since 1934; online ordering available.
Pine Aire Fish & Deli
140 Pine Aire Drive
Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-231-4467
Fresh fish market with a deli and prepared seafood; catering information is available through the business.
Catfish Annie’s
116 Commack Road
Commack, NY 11725
631-499-5131
Seafood market and prepared-food shop; call ahead for the current fresh-fish selection.
Island Fish
17 Kennedy Avenue
Farmingville, NY 11738
631-698-7700
Retail fish market offering fresh seafood and prepared items; contact the shop for ordering information.
Jeff’s Gourmet Market
110 New York Avenue
Halesite, NY 11743
631-427-5120
Gourmet seafood market with fresh fish and prepared foods; call for daily availability.
Fort Hill Seafood
113 E. Main Street
Huntington, NY 11743
631-427-2444
Neighborhood seafood market; contact the shop for current catch, prepared items and ordering.
Marty’s Gourmet Seafood
266 New York Avenue
Huntington, NY 11743
631-673-1888
Fresh seafood market offering prepared specialties and catering.
Northport Fish & Lobster
827 Fort Salonga Road
Northport, NY 11768
631-757-3474
Retail fish and lobster market where customers can select seafood from the case and have it prepared to order.
White Cap Fish Market
120 Main Street
Islip, NY 11751
631-581-0125
Fresh seafood market with prepared foods, catering, pickup and delivery.
Mastic Seafood
1051 Mastic Road
Mastic, NY 11950
631-281-9608
Retail and wholesale seafood market with prepared items and pickup ordering.
Land & Sea Fish Market
524 Route 25A
Mount Sinai, NY 11766
631-473-0011
Fresh fish market and restaurant offering raw seafood and cooked-to-order dishes.
J&M Seafood
248-B Larkfield Road
East Northport, NY 11731
631-306-4222
Retail seafood market with fresh fish, shellfish and prepared foods.
South Bay Seafood Co.
683 S. Country Road
East Patchogue, NY 11772
631-758-6846
Seafood market serving retail customers; call for current product availability and ordering.
PJ Lobster House
134 Main Street
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
631-473-1143
Fish market and seafood restaurant with pickup and delivery options.
Claws Seafood Market
20 Montauk Highway
West Sayville, NY 11796
631-256-5900
Seafood market and kitchen offering fresh fish, shellfish and prepared takeout.
Blue Water Fish
2 Sound Road
Wading River, NY 11792
631-886-2715
Fresh fish market and kitchen with same-day local catch when available, prepared meals and online ordering.
Multi Aquaculture Systems
429 Cranberry Hole Road
Amagansett, NY 11930
631-267-3341
Seafood market, takeout counter and fish farm offering fresh fish, shellfish and locally grown oysters.
Atlantic Seafood
117 Main Street
Center Moriches, NY 11934
631-878-8406
Fish market and restaurant emphasizing local and sustainable seafood; raw seafood and prepared dishes are available.
Braun Seafood
30840 Main Road
Cutchogue, NY 11935
631-734-7770
Long-running fish market and seafood distributor offering fresh and frozen seafood, a kitchen, catering and pickup.
Freedom Fishery
1049 Flanders Road
Flanders, NY 11901
631-871-4058
Roadside seafood stand selling fresh fish, hard clams and crabs; selection and hours vary.
Lighthouse Seafood
36 Lighthouse Road
Hampton Bays, NY 11946
631-728-5186
Retail fish market associated with Cor-J Seafood; call ahead for current local catch and hours.
Out of the Blue Seafood
252 E. Montauk Highway
Hampton Bays, NY 11946
631-728-3474
Fresh seafood market and wholesale supplier with pickup and delivery options.
Red Truck Seafood
87 Foster Avenue
Hampton Bays, NY 11946
631-728-9872
Retail seafood market; call or check current postings for the day’s catch and pickup information.
Montauk Seafood Company
12 S. Etna Avenue
Montauk, NY 11954
631-668-5957
Retail seafood market offering fresh fish and shellfish in Montauk; call for current availability.
North Fork Seafood
2495 Peconic Lane
Peconic, NY 11958
631-905-1123
Dock-to-dish market specializing in locally caught seafood, with online ordering, pickup and community-supported fishery shares.
Buoy One Seafood Market
40 Peconic Avenue, Unit 38
Riverhead, NY 11901
631-208-9737
Seafood market and restaurant offering fresh fish, shellfish and prepared takeout.
PE & DD Seafood’s Fish Shop
833 Middle Road
Riverhead, NY 11901
631-236-8770
Retail fish shop associated with Cor-J Seafood; contact the shop for current selection and hours.
Commander Cody Fish Shoppe
41 Smith Street
Shelter Island, NY 11964
631-749-1851
Seasonal-style neighborhood fish market and kitchen offering fresh seafood, prepared foods and takeout.
Clamman Seafood Market
235-A N. Sea Road
Southampton, NY 11968
631-283-6669
Seafood market and caterer selling fresh fish, shellfish and prepared specialties.
Southold Fish Market
64755 Main Road
Southold, NY 11971
631-765-3200
Fresh fish market with local seafood and an on-site kitchen for prepared meals and takeout.
Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market
211 Carpenter Street
Greenport, NY 11944
631-477-6992
Oyster farm market and raw bar where local oysters may be purchased to eat on site or take home; offerings are seasonal.
The Seafood Shop
356 Montauk Highway
Wainscott, NY 11975
631-537-0633
Fresh seafood market with prepared foods, catering and takeout.
Haskell’s Seafood Market & Cafe
77 Main Street
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
631-288-7287
Seafood market and cafe offering fresh fish, prepared foods, raw-bar items and takeout.
Mill Road Seafood
214 Mill Road
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
631-288-8184
Retail seafood market with pickup and delivery advertised; call for current selection and ordering.
Availability depends on weather, fishing seasons, quotas and what boats land on a particular day. Long Island waters may supply species such as fluke, porgy, black sea bass, striped bass, monkfish, squid, scallops, clams and oysters, but not every market carries local seafood every day. Ask where an item was harvested if local origin is important, and distinguish fresh product from seafood that was previously frozen and thawed.
Many markets will clean, fillet, shuck, steam or cook seafood to order, while others also sell soups, salads, seafood pies, sushi, platters and complete prepared meals. Ordering ahead is especially useful for live lobsters, whole fish, holiday platters, clambakes and larger quantities.
Methodology
This directory was compiled from the Cornell Cooperative Extension Choose Local F.I.S.H. seafood-market locator, official market websites and active business pages, supplemented by current local reporting where necessary. Inclusion required a physical Long Island location that sells uncooked seafood to the public for preparation elsewhere. Wholesale-only facilities, delivery-only services, ordinary supermarkets and restaurants without a genuine take-home fish market were excluded. Addresses, telephone numbers, public retail service and documented local-seafood claims were reviewed individually. The directory is intended to be comprehensive but not exhaustive, and businesses should be contacted directly because hours, ownership, services and seasonal operations can change.
From the Nautical Mile and South Shore fishing communities to North Fork docks and East End markets, Long Island offers numerous places to purchase fish and shellfish for home cooking. Calling ahead and asking what arrived that day is often the best way to find the freshest selection and learn which items were harvested locally.
