Where is the best pizza?

A classic New York-style pepperoni pizza with a crisp, golden crust and melted mozzarella showcases one of Long Island's most beloved comfort foods. From neighborhood pizzerias to family-owned Italian restaurants, great pizza has become a defining part of the island's culinary tradition. File photo: Alex Karlssonn, licensed. — A classic New York-style pepperoni pizza with a crisp, golden crust and melted mozzarella showcases one of Long Island’s most beloved comfort foods. From neighborhood pizzerias to family-owned Italian restaurants, great pizza has become a defining part of the island’s culinary tradition. File photo: Alex Karlssonn, licensed.

Long Island is home to hundreds of pizzerias, serving everything from traditional New York-style slices to gourmet specialty pies. Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese slice, a Sicilian square, or a wood-fired artisan pizza, outstanding neighborhood pizzerias can be found throughout Nassau County and Suffolk County.

In Short

Long Island’s pizza culture is deeply rooted in New York tradition. Family-owned pizzerias throughout the island serve freshly made dough, homemade sauces, quality cheeses, and a wide variety of toppings. Many residents have their own favorite neighborhood pizza shop, making Long Island one of the best places to enjoy authentic New York-style pizza.

Where Is the Best Pizza on Long Island?

Pizza is one of Long Island’s signature foods, with nearly every town offering locally owned pizzerias that have served generations of customers. From classic thin-crust New York-style slices to Sicilian, grandma, white, and specialty pizzas, the island’s pizza scene reflects decades of Italian-American culinary tradition.

Because pizza is such a personal favorite, opinions about the “best” pizzeria vary widely. Many Long Islanders remain loyal to the neighborhood shop they’ve visited for years, while visitors often enjoy exploring different communities to discover their own favorites.

If you’re looking for a place to start, popular local favorites include Taglio Pizza in Mineola and Little Vincent’s Pizza in Huntington. Taglio Pizza has earned international recognition as one of the world’s top pizzerias, while Little Vincent’s Pizza has become a longtime Suffolk County favorite known for its classic New York-style slices and local tradition.

Quick Facts

Looking For…	What You’ll Find
Traditional Pizza	Classic New York-style thin-crust pizza served throughout Long Island.
Popular Styles	Cheese, pepperoni, Sicilian, grandma, white, specialty, and gourmet pizzas.
Popular Nassau County Pizzeria	Taglio Pizza – Mineola – https://www.taglioromanpizza.com
Popular Suffolk County Pizzeria	Little Vincent’s Pizza – Huntington – https://www.instagram.com/little_vincents
More Choices	Outstanding independent pizzerias can be found in nearly every Long Island community.

Editorial Note: Recommendations on this page are chosen independently by the LongIslandGuide.com editorial team based on reputation, visitor experience, and local significance. Featured businesses do not pay for placement, and inclusion should not be interpreted as a ranking of all businesses on Long Island.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice for lunch or sitting down with family and friends, pizza remains one of Long Island’s most beloved culinary traditions. With exceptional neighborhood pizzerias across both counties, you’re never far from a great New York-style slice.