Best Towns to Raise a Family on Long Island

schools
From top schools to parks, beaches, and libraries, Long Island has much to offer growing families. While home prices and taxes may be high in some areas, the quality of life and community support often make it a worthwhile investment. File photo: Jaclyn Vernace, licensed.

Best Towns to Raise a Family on Long Island

Long Island is known for its top-rated schools, tight-knit communities, and family-friendly neighborhoods. But with dozens of towns and villages to choose from, deciding where to raise a family can be overwhelming. Whether you’re looking for great public schools, low crime rates, outdoor recreation, or a strong sense of community, these Long Island towns stand out as some of the best places to call home.

Garden City (Nassau County)

A picturesque village with tree-lined streets and historic homes, Garden City offers one of the most well-rounded family living experiences on Long Island.

  • Schools: Highly ranked public school district
  • Highlights: Walkable downtown, playgrounds, family events
  • Commute: 40 minutes to NYC via LIRR
  • Vibe: Upscale, suburban charm with a strong community feel

Great Neck (Nassau County)

Great Neck is known for its academic excellence, cultural diversity, and extensive parks.

  • Schools: Great Neck Public Schools rank among the top in the state
  • Highlights: Waterfront parks, public library system, music and arts programs
  • Commute: 30–40 minutes to NYC
  • Vibe: Diverse, intellectually driven, family-oriented

Port Washington (Nassau County)

With its scenic harbor and small-town feel, Port Washington blends coastal living with suburban convenience.

  • Schools: Highly regarded school district
  • Highlights: Waterfront parks, marinas, Main Street shops
  • Commute: Direct LIRR access to Manhattan
  • Vibe: Coastal, community-focused, artsy

Syosset (Nassau County)

Syosset offers excellent schools, safety, and easy access to both nature and amenities.

  • Schools: Syosset Central School District is top-tier
  • Highlights: Large homes, diverse dining, family-friendly neighborhoods
  • Commute: ~45 minutes to NYC
  • Vibe: Suburban, academically focused, diverse

Sayville (Suffolk County)

A charming South Shore village, Sayville is known for its community events and access to the Great South Bay.

  • Schools: Sayville School District ranks well in Suffolk County
  • Highlights: Main Street shops, ferries to Fire Island, marinas
  • Commute: Longer commute, but easy access to Sunrise Hwy and LIRR
  • Vibe: Quaint, laid-back, community-oriented

Smithtown (Suffolk County)

Smithtown combines affordability with a family-friendly lifestyle and ample green space.

  • Schools: Strong academic performance
  • Highlights: Caleb Smith State Park, public libraries, low crime
  • Commute: ~1 hour to NYC
  • Vibe: Classic suburban living with good value

East Setauket / Three Village Area (Suffolk County)

This historical and scenic area is home to one of the region’s best school districts and offers a quieter pace of life.

  • Schools: Three Village Central School District is top-rated
  • Highlights: Historic sites, nature trails, waterfront parks
  • Commute: 75–90 minutes to NYC (not ideal for daily commuting)
  • Vibe: Academic, peaceful, ideal for remote workers or local professionals

Choosing What Matters Most

The best town for your family depends on your priorities:

  • Schools: Great Neck, Syosset, East Setauket
  • Commute to NYC: Garden City, Port Washington
  • Affordability: Smithtown, Sayville
  • Community Events and Charm: Sayville, Garden City

Raising a Family on Long Island

From top schools to parks, beaches, and libraries, Long Island has much to offer growing families. While home prices and taxes may be high in some areas, the quality of life and community support often make it a worthwhile investment.